Difference Between 3PL and 4PL Logistics

Logistics is an inherent part of supply chain management that supports the flow of finished goods till the time it is delivered to the customers. In the complex world of supply chain management, it is essential to understand the proper logistics options that support your business needs where profits are maximised. The terms 3PL and 4PL are often used in a supply chain, but what exactly are 3PL and 4PL? In this article, we are going to explain the difference between 3PL and 4PL logistics, along with the features, advantages and disadvantages.
What is 3PL Logistics?
3PL stands for Third Party Logistics, and it refers to the outsourcing of particular logistics functions to a third party or an external service provider. The 3PL takes care of logistics functions on behalf of a business. Some functions that 3PL performs include warehousing, transportation, and distribution.
The key features of 3PL are explained below:
Primary Services
The primary service of 3PL includes transportation and managing freight operations and shipping. Also, warehousing and distribution are some of the primary functions that 3PL performs.
Offers Customisation
The services offered by 3PL can be tailored to meet the business needs in terms of logistics.
Integration of Technology
3PL companies are unknown in leveraging technology in order to provide services to a business for logistics. They use technologies such as warehouse management systems (WMS) and transportation management systems (TMS) to improve the process.
Scalability
With 3PL providers, it is easy for a business to scale up its logistics operations. Businesses also have an option to scale down their logistics operation. Hence, it is entirely flexible for businesses that deal with seasonal goods.
Advantages of 3PL
3PL offers numerous advantages when it comes to logistics operations for any business. Below are the advantages that a business can get via 3PL:
- When any business outsources logistics operations to a 3PL service provider, it eliminates the need for infrastructure and technology and the labour required to do the logistics operation. This can lead to significant cost efficiency.
- 3PL service providers offer complete flexibility when it comes to the scalability of any logistics operation in a business. Businesses can either scale up or scale down as per their business requirements.
- Businesses can delegate the logistics operation to 3PL providers and focus more on other parts of the supply chain. This helps to redirect the attention to the strategic growth of the business.
- 3PL providers have in-depth industry knowledge, which can help a business exercise its expertise in improving overall operational efficiency.
Disadvantages of 3PL
Along with several benefits, there are also a few limitations that businesses can face when dealing with a 3PL. Below are some of the disadvantages of 3PL:
- As other logistics operations under 3PL are redirected, businesses can find it tricky to oversee all the operations and functions remotely.
- The service’s quality and consistency can vary depending on the 3PL provider’s operational module.
- When the logistics operations of a business are dedicated to a third-party provider, it can increase the risk of potential disruption in terms of service due to overly depending upon the providers.
Related read – 10 Best 3PL (Third Party Logistics) Companies in India
What is 4PL Logistics?
4PL stands for Fourth Party Logistics. Contrary to the services offered by 3PL, 4PL logistics is beyond just managing the logistics. 4PL providers act as integrators that integrate all the aspects of the supply chain. Hence, a 4PL provider performs strategic and consultative roles, including multiple 3PL functions. The primary goal of having a 4PL is to ensure that there is seamless coordination across the entire supply chain.
The key features of 4PL are explained below:
Offers End-To-End Management
4PL providers work on a framework that helps a business with the entire supply chain process. Their functions include procurement, production, management, logistics, and also delivery. The primary aim of 4PL providers is to provide operational efficiency.
Strategic Partnership
Unlike 3PL, which focuses mainly on logistics operation and execution, 4PL providers offer strategic guidance. This guidance is helpful in optimising the supply chain performance and maximising the profits.
Vendor Management
One of the key functions of a 4PL provider is to coordinate with various stakeholders, suppliers, and also 3PL providers to streamline the complete supply chain operations.
Technological Use
In order to have a seamless supply chain operation, 4PL uses various innovative technologies like AI and Blockchain to improve functionality and productivity while providing real-time insights.
Advantages of 4PL
Businesses can harness various advantages via 4PL providers. Some of the advantages are listed below:
- 4PL providers offer seamless integration of all the processes and functions of a supply chain.
- With the help of analytics and technology, 4PL improves a business’s decision-making abilities.
- It helps to coordinate with all the stakeholders.
- 4PL providers aim to reduce the cost and improve the efficiency of the business.
Disadvantages of 4PL
Below are the disadvantages of 4PL:
- Given that 4PL services are more strategic and also include all the processes, they are more expensive compared to 3PL.
- As a 4PL service provider integrates all the services and processes under a supply chain, it can become tricky to have clear communications at times.
- Due to the comprehensive nature of the 4PL services, setting up and getting results can take longer.
3PL and 4PL Logistics Differences
Below is the table that explains the specific difference between 3PL and 4PL logistics concisely:
Comparison Aspect | 3PL (Third Party Logistics) | 4PL (Fourth Party Logistics) |
Scope | Operational in nature | Strategic and consultative |
Functions | Performs functions such as transportation, warehousing and distribution | Oversees and acts as an integrator for almost all the processes in the supply chain |
Control | Limited to particular services | Has complete control over the supply chain processes |
Technologies Used | Uses WMS and TMS | Uses ERP, AI and Blockchain |
Costing | Comparative lower | Higher as it performs functions that encompass all the processes of the supply chain |
Vendors Management | Is a vendor in a supply chain | Looks over functions from different vendors, including 3PL |
Customisation | Offers tailored experience | Provide end-to-end solutions |
Harness The Advantages of 3PL and 4PL Service From WareIQ
WareIQ is a Y-Combinator-backed eCommerce full-stack platform offering multi-channel fulfillment across D2C, Marketplaces, Quick Commerce, and B2B (General Trade & Modern Trade)
Our solution offers:
- Pan-India network of Seller Flex & FAssured compliant across 12+ cities operated by WareIQ and shipping partners for last-mile delivery across 27000+ pin codes
- Multi-Channel Fulfillment Platform with plug-and-play integrations across marketplaces (Amazon, Flipkart, Myntra, Nykaa, etc.), D2C platforms (Shopify, Magento, Woocommerce, etc.), WMS, and ERPs to support fulfilment across distributors, flagship stores and eCommerce channels with analytics capabilities to assess operational performance
- Inventory LogIQ: AI-led multi-channel inventory planning solution to minimise stockouts and automate replenishment
- Leverage Tech-enabled returns QC solution to capture, centrally store, and auto-index HD media evidence of damaged or missing returned products and eliminate marketplace claims rejections.
- A host of seller enablement and support – dedicated account manager, APOB/PPOB registrations, GST registration, NDR & COD verification, etc.
Suggested read – Is WareIQ a 3PL or 4PL, or Something Else?
Conclusion
In modern supply chain management, the functions are getting more complex each day. Hence, it becomes necessary to involve service providers like 3PL and 4PL to increase the efficiency and productivity of businesses. Choosing between 3PL and 4PL will depend on the business requirements in terms of end goals, complexity, and budget. Integrating 3PL and 4PL can help businesses get maximum benefits out of the different processes in the supply chain.
Also check – Types of Logistics
FAQs About 3PL and 4PL
Are 3PL services apt for small businesses?
Yes, services from 3PL providers are excellent for optimising the operations of a small business.
Can a business utilise 3PL and 4PL?
Yes, integrating both 3PL and 4PL will help businesses perform better.
Which service is more expensive?
4PL is more expensive than 3PL as it includes looking after the entire supply chain.
Which technology is used by 4PL?
4PL provider utilises technologies like ERP, AI and Blockchain
Is 4PL better than 3PL?
It is entirely up to the requirements of a business. If a business is exclusively looking for logistics services, then 3PL is better. If businesses are looking for end-to-ed support, then 4PL is better.